Judge orders province to disclose who cut Tesla from EV rebate program
Advertisement
Read this article for free:
or
Already have an account? Log in here »
We need your support!
Local journalism needs your support!
As we navigate through unprecedented times, our journalists are working harder than ever to bring you the latest local updates to keep you safe and informed.
Now, more than ever, we need your support.
Starting at $15.99 plus taxes every four weeks you can access your Brandon Sun online and full access to all content as it appears on our website.
Subscribe Nowor call circulation directly at (204) 727-0527.
Your pledge helps to ensure we provide the news that matters most to your community!
To continue reading, please subscribe:
Add Brandon Sun access to your Free Press subscription for only an additional
$1 for the first 4 weeks*
- Enjoy unlimited reading on brandonsun.com
- Read the Brandon Sun E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
*Your next Free Press subscription payment will increase by $1.00 and you will be charged $20.95 plus GST for four weeks. After four weeks, your payment will increase to $24.95 plus GST every four weeks.
Read unlimited articles for free today:
or
Already have an account? Log in here »
WINNIPEG — A Manitoba judge has ordered the NDP government to disclose who decided to exclude Tesla Motors Canada from its electric vehicle rebate program — and explain the reasoning behind it.
In a judgment issued on Nov. 13, Court of King’s Bench Justice Elissa Neville ordered the provincial government to produce a “complete record” of its decision-making process in disqualifying anyone who bought a Tesla vehicle after March 19, 2025 from its electric vehicle tax rebate.
The government has until Monday to file an affidavit with the court explaining the decision, which Tesla had asked a judge to review and overturn earlier this year.
Tesla has argued the provincial government’s decision was unreasonable, procedurally unfair and not transparent, asserting that it’s unclear who made the decision to exclude the company from the program and if they were legally authorized to do so.
The province has argued its exclusion of the company cannot be reviewed by a judge because it was a government funding decision and moved to have the application quashed.
But the judge, in part, agreed with Tesla.
Neville found she could not make any determination on Tesla’s court application, filed in late May, because she, too, does not know who made the decision.
The judge described the province as displaying “a baffling coyness” about the process in its court filings. She found the record filed with the court “sheds no light whatsoever” on who made the decision, why it was made and whether it can be reviewed by the court.
Neville acknowledged it is atypical for the court to order a government to explain the rationale behind its decisions, but she found it was the most practical thing to do in the unusual case.
“I acknowledge that compelling the respondents to file their record by way of an affidavit is an exceptional and unusual remedy,” Neville said in her written decision.
“That said, in the specific and unique circumstances of this case, where the respondents refuse to identify anyone as the decision maker, such an approach strikes me as the more practical and efficient means of ensuring that there is a clear and streamlined record before the court.”
Finance Minister Adrien Sala announced Tesla’s exclusion from the program, which MPI administers, in March 2025 under the province’s “commitment to be elbows up” in retaliation for tariffs imposed by U.S. President Donald Trump who, at the time, had given Elon Musk, the CEO of Texas-based Tesla Inc., a job in his administration. The government also excluded Chinese-made electric vehicles at the time.
The Canadian subsidiary has argued it does not operate in the U.S., nor does it have a role or involvement with the U.S. administration.
Tesla Canada has argued its exclusion cost consumers about $560,000 and went against the purpose of the province’s rebate program.
Rebates of up to $4,000 were first offered in 2024. Manitoba Public Insurance administers the program.
Tesla decided to launch its court challenge when the exclusion was extended in March for the 2026-27 fiscal year.
The province said earlier this year more than 5,000 Manitobans have received a rebate since the program started, with $25 million in funding allocated.
Neville said Tesla Canada has argued, in the absence of a proper record, it only has media reports and remarks made publicly by the premier to use to try to understand the government’s rationale to exclude it.
The province has argued the change to the program was a policy decision and can’t be reviewed by the court, but Neville said she can’t rule on that argument without further details.
“The applicant is entitled to seek to challenge a decision affecting its interests. The respondents intend to argue in this case that the decision the applicant challenges is not reviewable because it is a policy decision. I cannot make that determination without knowing who the decision-maker was,” Neville wrote.
“For some reason, the respondents are saying that it is for the court to make that determination, even though the respondents have neither taken a position nor provided the information necessary for me to do (that).”
Neville will also hear the province’s motion to strike Tesla Canada’s application at the same time as the application. A hearing is set for Dec. 22.
Tesla Canada had named MPI in its court application, but abandoned it as a respondent after it accepted the public insurer did not make the decision to exclude it from the program.
Premier Wab Kinew’s office said he had no comment for the Winnipeg Free Press, but on Thursday morning he addressed it during an interview on CJOB.
“You tell me, the richest man in the world needs your taxpayer dollars? That doesn’t seem like a good use of funds. We have so many asks for the provincial treasury,” he said.
Progressive Conservative finance critic Lauren Stone slammed the government.
“The ruling from (Justice) Neville is another example of Wab Kinew avoiding accountability for decisions made in his government,” said Stone. “He is wasting Manitobans’ tax dollars based on a personal vendetta, and Manitobans deserve transparency.”
» Winnipeg Free Press